The historic Holly Inn is located in Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania. It lies in the Gap of the South Mountains in Cumberland County. This beloved inn nestles in the gorge that the Mountain Creek flows through, where the changes of seasons bring color and drama. Natives tell the story that the Holly Inn started as a “shack” by the mountains. By the late 1700’s the shack was transformed into a small log tavern.

In 1804, the log tavern was replaced by a stone building solidly built with sandstone from the local quarries. Only then was it called an inn. Because the surrounding landscape was peppered with holly trees, it was given the name that it still bears today, the Holly Inn.

Silent Witness

The Holly Inn was a silent witness during the Civil War. Cannon and gunfire reverberated through the South mountains, shouts and cries of battle were heard in the Gap. More than 40,000 Confederate and Union men passed through Mount Holly Springs on their way to Gettysburg.

A skirmish ensued in front of the Holly Inn and a member of General Richard Ewell’s 2nd Corps was injured in June 1863. He was left at the Holly Inn to be cared for. His condition deteriorated steadily and he died several days later.

No one knew who the Confederate soldier was, and there was no clue to his identity among his effects. This casualty of the Civil War was buried in the borough cemetery and thus became the unknown soldier of Mount Holly Springs. Civil War Photo 2To this day families of buried unknown soldiers come to search for clues on whether this brave soldier was their loved one.

View the Civil War Photo Gallery.

In the late 1960’s the Inn went through extensive renovations with preservation of the original grey stone building. The restaurant is in this buiding; several heritage rooms located above the restaurant. The tavern was created by the enclosure of the porch on the building south side. The part of the original Inn that was the three story hotel was replaced in the 1960’s with a  Banquet Hall and ten hotel rooms. The banquet hall has been, and continues to be the site of many memorable weddings, receptions and other social events.

The average temperature of Mount Holly Springs is 8 degrees cooler than its surrounding cities, thus the Holly Inn quickly became a popular summer resort for guests from New York City, Philadelphia, Baltimore and Washington, DC. The Inn developed into a hotel that comfortably accommodated as many as one hundred guests. The beauty and serenity of the mountains provide a natural setting for outdoor activities and encouraged restful visits. Guests who came to the Inn to recuperate from serious illnesses also enjoyed the benefits of the pure water that flows from the neighboring streams.

In 2003, the Holly Inn Group Inc. a group of friends and family members, acquired the Inn which had lain idle for a number of years. They made extensive and necessary renovations. These included access for guests with disabilities, a completely new deck by the mountain creek, and the restoration and furnishing of all 14 guest rooms. Each guest room is unique in its design and all have private baths. The four rooms above the most historic part of the building is coined the Heritage Section, two of which were enlarged with  whirlpool installed. The large capacity Banquet Hall with a roomy dancing floor was refurbished and fully equipped for social and  business functions. Special care was taken to faithfully retain the  charm of the historical  part of the building, a true landmark. The original 200 plus year old sandstone walls, about two feet thick were carefully restored. The renovations revealed construction methods of yesteryear, such as  horse and human hair with plaster and other fascinating relics of a much earlier time.

A large stone wall, the original exterior, was rediscovered and now carefully preserved to be savored by guests in the Heritage section. Despite the many changes in the Holly Inn structure, its exterior remains the same familiar face well loved by the close knit neighborhood.

Diners can now feast on our favorite dishes like Crab soup and Crab Cakes, as well as our meat and seafood specials. The tavern offers a wide array of choices for drinks.  Two large screen TVs show ongoing events.

The unique setting of the historic Inn, the charm and warmth of its atmosphere, and the natural beauty of the Gap in the South Mountains make it very inviting. Guests tend to return year after year. The members of the Holly Inn Group are pleased to be a part of this vibrant history of the Holly Inn and of Mount Holly Springs.

Join us on Sunday Feb 3 for SUPERBOWL PARTY! You can reserve now for Valentine's Special Dinner on Feb 14, call 717-486-3823. Mark your calendar for Gina Clowes' Band, bluegrass on Feb 24, 8pm tickets are $20.

The Holly Inn, the bicentennial greystone, located at 31 South Baltimore Avenue, Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, has the charm of history and is uniquely designed to accommodate lodging, smart casual dining, tavern and banquet hall. Come savor our famous cream of crab soup and crab cakes, as well as our meat and seafood specials.

Holly Inn
31 South Baltimore Avenue
Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania 17065

(717) 486-3823 or (717) 486-4194
(717) 486-4659 Fax

Learn more

The best and most beautiful things in the world cannot be seen or even touched. They must be felt with the heart! ... Helen Keller
Happy Valentine’s Day
... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Super Bowl party @ the Holly Inn Tavern for $4 enjoy a buffet of hamburger, BBQ chicken, hot dogs, buffalo dip potatoe salad, chips & dips- wishing our Eagles the best of Luck! ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Join us @ Holly Inn’s Super Bowl party on Sunday starting @ 6pm ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

You and Your Sweetheart Will Love
Valentine’s Dinner at the Holly Inn!

Wednesday, February 14, 2018


Cheese and Berry Platter – Mixed berries and cheeses, served with crackers and red wine mustard - $12.95
Crab ragoon – crab/cream cheese blend in won ton wrappers, fried, with sweet & sour dipping sauce - $8.95
Chicken Kebob – Honey bourbon chicken, tomato, pineapple, and red peppers - $6.95


Grilled Filet Mignon with roasted red potatoes and sautéed vegetables - $27.95
Prime Rib topped with horseradish and bourbon glaze and served with roasted red potatoes and sautéed vegetables - $22.95
Flounder fillet stuffed with crabmeat and topped with parmesan imperial sauce, with roasted red potatoes and sautéed vegetables - $24.95
Roasted duck with orange ginger marmalade over wild rice, with sautéed vegetables - $24.95
Chicken Marsala with roasted red potatoes and sautéed vegetables - $17.95
Eggplant Parmesan, served over spaghetti, with a bread stick - $ 18.95
Vodka shrimp scampi served over fettucine, with a bread stick - $20.95


Chocolate Covered Strawberries for Two - $10.95
Red velvet mini cake - $6.95
Raspberry Crème Brulée - $6.95

Call for reservations today!
... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Congratulations to the Penguins on their 45th year. They braved the 60 degree drop in temperature as they hiked & camped out @ Col Denning Park. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook
Restaurant Hours
Sunday - Thursday
11:30 a.m. - 9:00 p.m.

Friday - Saturday
11:30 a.m. - 10:00 p.m.

Tavern Hours

Monday - Thursday
11:30 a.m. - 10:00 p.m.

Friday - Saturday
11:30 a.m. - Midnight

11:30 a.m. - 11:00 p.m.

Tavern Photo 1

Friday Evening Bands, Saturday Karaoke, & Sunday Open Mic.

Member in Good Standing
Carlisle Chamber of Commerce